Omega Owners Forum

Omega Help Area => Omega General Help => Topic started by: steve6367 on 05 May 2014, 09:23:40

Title: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 05 May 2014, 09:23:40
Well it still generally runs better that it had for some time, so hopeful I've done nothing too silly.

However:

Cold start (sat over night) perfect, but it does not hold first couple of gear changes to higher revs.

Hot start (off for less than an hour) perfect

Warm start (3 or 4 hours after switch off) - starts immediately and is using rich mixture and increased idle speed but very lumpy. If you hold revs at 2k smooths out and if you give it 20 seconds of that all seems well. After this it also holds the first couple of gear changes until higher revs as expected on cold start to warm cats.

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.

I've had a really good look over the engine and can't find anything out of order.

Any thoughts from the panel?

Many thanks

Steve

Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: TheBoy on 05 May 2014, 09:50:26
What engine?

Given the code, be suspicious of MAF, airleaks in intake/exhaust or front lamda(s).
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: TheBoy on 05 May 2014, 09:50:54
LOL, its in title ;D

The same applies though :y
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 05 May 2014, 10:31:32
Thanks - inlet side I've been over and MAF is only 6 months old, will take a look at live data from it though to see it looks sensible, I m learning not to assume anything! Exhaust is blowing slightly beyond the CAT section so sounds like I should get that changed. Can it cause problems even if blow is beyond both lambda?

Steve
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: SIR Philbutt on 05 May 2014, 13:24:37
......

Cold start (sat over night) perfect, but it does not hold first couple of gear changes to higher revs.


Assuming it's an auto that is normal, warming the ATF, thats why OK when warm

......

Warm start (3 or 4 hours after switch off) - starts immediately and is using rich mixture and increased idle speed but very lumpy. If you hold revs at 2k smooths out and if you give it 20 seconds of that all seems well. After this it also holds the first couple of gear changes until higher revs as expected on cold start to warm cats.


I would assume that is the same thing, like auto-choke was in older cars

...

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.


Mine does that and have concluded it is when switch on/off LPG. If not causing a permanent spanner light (only when ign on - not running) it is not something of great significance IMO

HTH
Phil
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 06 May 2014, 21:18:00
......

Cold start (sat over night) perfect, but it does not hold first couple of gear changes to higher revs.


Assuming it's an auto that is normal, warming the ATF, thats why OK when warm

......

Warm start (3 or 4 hours after switch off) - starts immediately and is using rich mixture and increased idle speed but very lumpy. If you hold revs at 2k smooths out and if you give it 20 seconds of that all seems well. After this it also holds the first couple of gear changes until higher revs as expected on cold start to warm cats.


I would assume that is the same thing, like auto-choke was in older cars

...

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.


Mine does that and have concluded it is when switch on/off LPG. If not causing a permanent spanner light (only when ign on - not running) it is not something of great significance IMO

HTH
Phil

Thanks - can you clarify? I thought the auto box should allow higher revs before gear change on a cold start to warm the CAT's quicker?
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Gaffers on 06 May 2014, 21:20:10
Thanks - inlet side I've been over and MAF is only 6 months old

Genuine or pattern?
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 06 May 2014, 22:41:56
Thanks - inlet side I've been over and MAF is only 6 months old
Genuine or pattern?

Bosch, but not new from a breaker....
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: SIR Philbutt on 06 May 2014, 23:58:56
......

Cold start (sat over night) perfect, but it does not hold first couple of gear changes to higher revs.


Assuming it's an auto that is normal, warming the ATF, thats why OK when warm

......

Warm start (3 or 4 hours after switch off) - starts immediately and is using rich mixture and increased idle speed but very lumpy. If you hold revs at 2k smooths out and if you give it 20 seconds of that all seems well. After this it also holds the first couple of gear changes until higher revs as expected on cold start to warm cats.


I would assume that is the same thing, like auto-choke was in older cars

...

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.


Mine does that and have concluded it is when switch on/off LPG. If not causing a permanent spanner light (only when ign on - not running) it is not something of great significance IMO

HTH
Phil

Thanks - can you clarify? I thought the auto box should allow higher revs before gear change on a cold start to warm the CAT's quicker?

That as well  :-[
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Kevin Wood on 07 May 2014, 10:34:02
...

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.


Mine does that and have concluded it is when switch on/off LPG. If not causing a permanent spanner light (only when ign on - not running) it is not something of great significance IMO

HTH
Phil

I would say it is significant. On an LPG car it usually indicates that the LPG system is poorly mapped. On a petrol car it's an indication that something is significantly degrading the accuracy of the fuelling. There is quite a wide margin of adjustment before this code is stored, so something has gone badly wrong if this code is being reported. As said, air leaks, MAF and lambda sensor issues are the usual suspects.
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Gaffers on 07 May 2014, 10:58:26
First port of call:

- Test the MAF by unplugging it, see if it runs better.
- Test for air leaks by blipping the throttle and listening for those unmistakable whistles

Then you are in to needing a reader to watch live data for the lambdas.  Double-check it is correctly plugged in though, it can be easy to forget or not quite push home :y
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 07 May 2014, 12:35:07
Thank you both - I only have a very limited window to do any testing as it runs perfectly, except on a warm start for around 20 seconds.

I know if parked at work for the day it will play up when started, so can try unplugging the MAF before I do so and see what happens. When I do that does it assume a MAF value? Or just run open loop?

MAF and Lambda live data looks ok, but I don't have Tech 2 - also the freeze frame data attached to the code stored shows a MAF value 0.0gm/s which clearly can't be correct.

I wonder if I have 2 different issues here to be honest.

Could the Lambda sensors have been damaged by all the steam in the exhaust when the HG went?

Steve
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Kevin Wood on 07 May 2014, 12:36:57
Can you see the fuel trims in your live data?
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 07 May 2014, 13:07:40
From the Freeze Frame if that helps, I can also see when in live data but don't have the car with me currently.

Freeze Frame data
Fault code   Sensor   Value
P0170   Sensor values:   
Calculated Load   55.29 %
Coolant Temperature   86. C
Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   12.5 %
Long Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   11.72 %

Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 2   -100. %
Engine Speed   2426 rpm
Vehicle Speed   42 mph
Ignition Timing Advance   63.50 º
Intake Air Temperature   32.00 ºC
Air Flow Rate (MAF)   0.00 g/s
Absolute Throttle Position   7.06 %
Oxygen Sensor 1 - Bank 1 voltage   0.42 V
Oxygen Sensor 2 - Bank 1 voltage   0.42 V
Fuel System 1 Status   Closed Loop
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Jimbob on 07 May 2014, 14:57:31
Maf reading 0 according to that.

Air temp also seems hot

What device are you using?
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Kevin Wood on 07 May 2014, 15:11:04
63.5 degree ignition advance too! :o

That live data doesn't look trustworthy to me. :(
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 07 May 2014, 15:48:47
Gendan EngineCheck Pro with ELM327 v1.4b USB interface.

That is a freeze frame which I think it takes from the ECU? (although clearly the reader could screw it up in the process). When I get home I can grab some live data and post, certainly the MAF does not show 0 there.

Or are we just saying my reader is giving me rubbish?  >:(

Steve
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 07 May 2014, 15:54:00
Here is another Freeze Frame from a different date - i.e. the fault has been logged, cleared and returned several times:

Freeze Frame data
Fault code   Sensor Value P0170   
Sensor values:   
Calculated Load   63.53 %
Coolant Temperature   78. C
Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   12.5 %
Long Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   11.72 %
Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 2   -100. %
Engine Speed   2725 rpm
Vehicle Speed   67 mph
Ignition Timing Advance   7.50 º
Intake Air Temperature   17.00 ºC
Air Flow Rate (MAF)   2.67 g/s
Absolute Throttle Position   2.75 %
Oxygen Sensor 1 - Bank 1 voltage   0.12 V
Oxygen Sensor 2 - Bank 1 voltage   0.42 V
Fuel System 1 Status   Closed Loop
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 07 May 2014, 16:01:25
One more (last one!) from when the HG Failed and is was misfiring:

Freeze Frame data
Fault code   Sensor Value P0302   
Sensor values:   
Calculated Load   71.37 %
Coolant Temperature   93. C
Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   0. %
Long Term Fuel Trim Bank 1   11.72 %
Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 2   -100. %
Engine Speed   3119 rpm
Vehicle Speed   30 mph
Ignition Timing Advance   63.50 º
Intake Air Temperature   14.00 ºC
Air Flow Rate (MAF)   0.00 g/s
Absolute Throttle Position   7.06 %
Oxygen Sensor 1 - Bank 1 voltage   0.42 V
Oxygen Sensor 2 - Bank 1 voltage   0.42 V
Fuel System 1 Status   Open Loop (accelerating)
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 08 May 2014, 19:18:25
Today ECL on and:

Freeze Frame data
Fault code  Sensor  Value P1130 
Sensor values:   
 Calculated Load  33.33 %
 Coolant Temperature  87. C
 Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 1  12.5 %
 Long Term Fuel Trim Bank 1  11.72 %
 Short Term Fuel Trim Bank 2  -100. %
 Engine Speed  1807 rpm
 Vehicle Speed  44 mph
 Ignition Timing Advance  6.00 º
 Intake Air Temperature  33.00 ºC
 Air Flow Rate (MAF)  3.93 g/s
 Absolute Throttle Position  3.92 %
 Oxygen Sensor 1 - Bank 1 voltage  0.37 V
 Oxygen Sensor 2 - Bank 1 voltage  0.42 V
 Fuel System 1 Status  Closed Loop

Some live data after code cleared:

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/livedatagrid_zps6be2ed33.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/livedatagrid_zps6be2ed33.jpg.html)

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/lambdaboth_zps09b050e0.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/lambdaboth_zps09b050e0.jpg.html)

Code would suggest Lambda? Although they both look fine on the graph  :o Still driving fine other than brief rough running on a warm start.

Steve
     
 
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 09 May 2014, 11:39:33
Maf reading 0 according to that.

Air temp also seems hot

What device are you using?

Does anyone know what they normally get? The 28C in my live data was with an amdient of 12C.
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 09 May 2014, 18:09:14
Any thoughts on the data posted? Or anymore diagnostics anyone?

Bit of shame after getting the HG done to have the ECL light on all the time and I gues it wont pass its MOT next month either :-(

Steve
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: SIR Philbutt on 09 May 2014, 23:26:21
...

Plugging in I have stored P0170 Fuel Trim Malfunction.


Mine does that and have concluded it is when switch on/off LPG. If not causing a permanent spanner light (only when ign on - not running) it is not something of great significance IMO

HTH
Phil

I would say it is significant. On an LPG car it usually indicates that the LPG system is poorly mapped. On a petrol car it's an indication that something is significantly degrading the accuracy of the fuelling. There is quite a wide margin of adjustment before this code is stored, so something has gone badly wrong if this code is being reported. As said, air leaks, MAF and lambda sensor issues are the usual suspects.

Kevin - to ellaborate.

It seems to happen if the LPG tries to switch in at the "wrong time", eg accellerating. Also if the LPG runs out when accellerating or at high speed. This tends to cause a slight "stutter" during the transition and then next time I switch on the ign the spanner light does not go out until the engine is started (normally would go out after a couple of sec's). The code is the only one stored when I get the chance to check.

So, before I go and try looking for something wrong, is there something I could find and resolve.

The LPG system is professionaly installed and serviced and mapping checked every year and I have always had this occurance with both my LPG'd cars
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 12 May 2014, 17:42:13
So I've been over it agian at the weekend and can't find any trapped wiring, air leaks etc

Driving home today and on comes the EML, but nice and near home so I can leave it running and get the code reader on:

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/o2sensorsfailed2_zps1e26f27b.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/o2sensorsfailed2_zps1e26f27b.jpg.html)

Live Lambda data:

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/o2sensorsfailed_zpsd43fcb22.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/o2sensorsfailed_zpsd43fcb22.jpg.html)

Then switch off and back on again and:

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/o2sensorsfailed3engineoffandbackon_zpsded5139a.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/o2sensorsfailed3engineoffandbackon_zpsded5139a.jpg.html)

This all looks a little strange to me. Does the actual ECU often go wrong as I am not sure I believe what it is reporting now.

Steve
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 12 May 2014, 23:04:12
Any thoughts from the panel?  :o
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Andy A on 13 May 2014, 08:01:16
Gendan EngineCheck Pro with ELM327 v1.4b USB interface.

That is a freeze frame which I think it takes from the ECU? (although clearly the reader could screw it up in the process). When I get home I can grab some live data and post, certainly the MAF does not show 0 there.

Or are we just saying my reader is giving me rubbish?  >:(

Steve

Steve, does the EngineCheck Pro software, cover all Vauxhauls? I was told that I would need to use the Vauxcheck software with the Omega when I asked.
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 13 May 2014, 18:20:52
Gendan EngineCheck Pro with ELM327 v1.4b USB interface.

That is a freeze frame which I think it takes from the ECU? (although clearly the reader could screw it up in the process). When I get home I can grab some live data and post, certainly the MAF does not show 0 there.

Or are we just saying my reader is giving me rubbish?  >:(

Steve

Steve, does the EngineCheck Pro software, cover all Vauxhauls? I was told that I would need to use the Vauxcheck software with the Omega when I asked.

2001 onwards they say yes (it does not work on my Saloon which is older) - it certainly has worked ok since I've had it. I'm just not convinced by what it is telling me and I don't have any past live data to use for comparison.

Fingers cross someone will and can advise further......
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: Andy A on 13 May 2014, 19:22:09
Gendan EngineCheck Pro with ELM327 v1.4b USB interface.

That is a freeze frame which I think it takes from the ECU? (although clearly the reader could screw it up in the process). When I get home I can grab some live data and post, certainly the MAF does not show 0 there.

Or are we just saying my reader is giving me rubbish?  >:(

Steve

Steve, does the EngineCheck Pro software, cover all Vauxhauls? I was told that I would need to use the Vauxcheck software with the Omega when I asked.

2001 onwards they say yes (it does not work on my Saloon which is older) - it certainly has worked ok since I've had it. I'm just not convinced by what it is telling me and I don't have any past live data to use for comparison.

Fingers cross someone will and can advise further......

Lets hope so Steve. Good luck with it.
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 13 May 2014, 20:44:07
Thank you the MOT is getting a little close now!

 ???
Title: Re: Post HG change issue on 2.2
Post by: steve6367 on 05 August 2014, 14:51:14
Well whole new exhaust and another post CAT Lambda and it passed the MOT  :y

Does the below help at all?

(http://i429.photobucket.com/albums/qq19/steve6367/Omega/img-140805195118-0001_zps5cce3368.jpg) (http://s429.photobucket.com/user/steve6367/media/Omega/img-140805195118-0001_zps5cce3368.jpg.html)