Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: mantahatch on 15 January 2009, 21:27:24

Title: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: mantahatch on 15 January 2009, 21:27:24
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/7832191.stm

Some very lucky people.
Title: Re: Plan crash, not a joke.
Post by: albitz on 15 January 2009, 21:30:01
Sems like they had a lucky escape,would have thought the temperature in the Hudson would be enough to kill you at this time of year. :o
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 15 January 2009, 21:55:58
Nasty, and a lucky escape.

One journalistic gem, though:
Quote
Bird strikes disabled two of the plane's engines, officials said.

Two of the plane's two engines, in fact, hence the involvement of the Hudson river.

Would have been an entirely different story if that take-off had been from Heathrow. :o Still, let's build a 3rd runway anyway.

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Entwood on 15 January 2009, 22:16:14
Probably the only reason they all survived was the pilots decision to go for the river.... so no impact destruction and no fire .... if they had hit terra firma with a full fuel load ..... :(

Nice one to the crew  :y :y :y :y
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 15 January 2009, 22:19:53
Quote
Probably the only reason they all survived was the pilots decision to go for the river.... so no impact destruction and no fire .... if they had hit terra firma with a full fuel load ..... :(

Nice one to the crew  :y :y :y :y

Yep, some quick thinking under pressure there.

He must have done well to bleed most of his speed off before touching the water too, otherwise it would have broken up.

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Ian_D on 16 January 2009, 02:52:46
Quote
Quote
Probably the only reason they all survived was the pilots decision to go for the river.... so no impact destruction and no fire .... if they had hit terra firma with a full fuel load ..... :(

Nice one to the crew  :y :y :y :y

Yep, some quick thinking under pressure there.

He must have done well to bleed most of his speed off before touching the water too, otherwise it would have broken up.

Kevin

Agree, top job  :y

Amazing to see the plane intact in the water, must have been a controlled, slow emergency landing.
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Sad on 16 January 2009, 08:27:36
Great job by the pilot...   :)  :y
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Gaffers on 16 January 2009, 08:51:32
Quote
Probably the only reason they all survived was the pilots decision to go for the river.... so no impact destruction and no fire .... if they had hit terra firma with a full fuel load ..... :(

Nice one to the crew  :y :y :y :y

Spoke to my wife the 'trolly dolly' about this and in fact water ditching is the last option.  Statistically planes that attempt to crash land on water fare worse than those on terra firma.  I guess it was the lack of flat land that made the pilot choose to ditch on water.

Some very very lucky people and one very skilled pilot  :y

Also I bet people are paing more attention to the safety demo after this  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 16 January 2009, 08:57:12
Spare a thought for the poor flock of geese !
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Debs. on 16 January 2009, 09:04:18
Quote
Spare a thought for the poor flock of geese !

They wouldn`t feel a thing......only barely enough time to think; "WTF is that big white........?" ;)

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y2OS2pwrZTI&feature=related[/media]
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: omegod on 16 January 2009, 09:30:13
I would imagine he will be dropping off his uniform pants at the dry cleaners as we speak !

What a landing though, if either wing had clipped the water it would have broken up for sure.
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 16 January 2009, 09:36:54
Just a reminder of how it could so easuily have gone.  :(

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ESJx5bJIP5o

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: doog on 16 January 2009, 09:50:24
Quote
Just a reminder of how it could so easuily have gone.  :(

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ESJx5bJIP5o

Kevin

that was an uncontrolled landing of a hijacked plane as it had ran out of fuel
very different from what happened last night  but yes i would rather land landing gear down on something hard than in water.
Doug
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: doog on 16 January 2009, 09:52:37
very lucky no one was injured  (5 animals died they were being transported in the hold and drowned)
anyone know how long  a plane will float for ?

doug
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Gaffers on 16 January 2009, 10:13:38
Quote
very lucky no one was injured  (5 animals died they were being transported in the hold and drowned)
anyone know how long  a plane will float for ?

doug

depends on the type of aircraft, amount of damage sustained to the fuselage, amount of fuel remaining, laden weight and the water conditions
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: gwa on 16 January 2009, 10:21:16
Surely the pilot must have it going really slow, cos when anything hits water its like hitting a brick wall 'instant stop'. Followed by breakup and god knows what, spot on bloke that pilot.

 :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y

Maybe Tony Blair should give the pilot the United States' highest civil award - the Medal of Freedom

 ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Entwood on 16 January 2009, 10:27:53
Quote
Surely the pilot must have it going really slow, cos when anything hits water its like hitting a brick wall 'instant stop'. Followed by breakup and god knows what, spot on bloke that pilot.

 :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y :y

Maybe Tony Blair should give the pilot the United States' highest civil award - the Medal of Freedom

 ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D


The ideal speed for ditching is usually Vstall + 10 knots .. this gives sufficient forward speed for aerodynamic control AND ensures a "glancing" or "shallow" touchdown... without bouncing. It is a vertical impact on water that is akin to hitting concrete, which is why you don't "stall" on or bounce. The Vstall+10 will also give  a high nose up attitude so that the flat "belly" of the aircraft takes the impact.. but not too high a nose-up that on impact the aircraft rotates suddenly nosedown and "smacks" into the surface.

These things are practiced in simulators by all pilots, but nothing can prepare you for actually having to do it.

This pilot appears to have done everything right ...

so Congratulations Sir ... you should never have to buy a beer again  :y :y :y :y
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Omega man 2 on 16 January 2009, 11:05:59
Quote
Quote
very lucky no one was injured  (5 animals died they were being transported in the hold and drowned)
anyone know how long  a plane will float for ?

doug

depends on the type of aircraft, amount of damage sustained to the fuselage, amount of fuel remaining, laden weight and the water conditions

It was still floating at 1 this morning. Even a couple of hours after everyone escaped :o
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 16 January 2009, 21:42:05
You can see it all replayed here:

http://www4.passur.com/lga.html

Set date to Jan 15th, time to 15:25 and range to 10 miles.

You can see AWE1549 take off in green a minute or two in, from the centre of the sceen heading upwards. Climbs to about 3,400 feet and then starts a rapid descent followed by a tight turn to the left to reach the river. You can see one light aircraft heading up the river the opposite way at 1,000 feet take avoiding action and then go back for a look, accompanied by another, which seems to hover in the area.

Have a look at La Guardia on google earth and you can see that was his only option.  He was down to 1,300 feet when he reached the river. :o

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: stuart30 on 16 January 2009, 21:58:15
Well id say the pilot has balls...heard something on the radio about how even seasoned pilots often panic when in such a situation and by all accounts this guy kept calm and took control of what could have been a disaster.

Really hope he receives the rewards he deserves.... :y

Lucky that wasnt on the Thames...would have probably got a bloody parking ticket. ;D
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Lazydocker on 16 January 2009, 22:27:00
That was fascinating Kevin :y :y :y

Pleased to hear the pilot is being acknowledged for his bravery :y :y :y :y
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Ian_D on 17 January 2009, 01:05:07
Quote
You can see it all replayed here:

http://www4.passur.com/lga.html

Set date to Jan 15th, time to 15:25 and range to 10 miles.

You can see AWE1549 take off in green a minute or two in, from the centre of the sceen heading upwards. Climbs to about 3,400 feet and then starts a rapid descent followed by a tight turn to the left to reach the river. You can see one light aircraft heading up the river the opposite way at 1,000 feet take avoiding action and then go back for a look, accompanied by another, which seems to hover in the area.

Have a look at La Guardia on google earth and you can see that was his only option.  He was down to 1,300 feet when he reached the river. :o

Kevin

Very intresting! Love things like that!

Have some software on the laptop (acarsd maybe?) that displays planes on a map and the flight info. Can do it over the internet or by plugging it into my scanner!  :)
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 17 January 2009, 01:35:27
Quote
Quote
You can see it all replayed here:

http://www4.passur.com/lga.html

Set date to Jan 15th, time to 15:25 and range to 10 miles.

You can see AWE1549 take off in green a minute or two in, from the centre of the sceen heading upwards. Climbs to about 3,400 feet and then starts a rapid descent followed by a tight turn to the left to reach the river. You can see one light aircraft heading up the river the opposite way at 1,000 feet take avoiding action and then go back for a look, accompanied by another, which seems to hover in the area.

Have a look at La Guardia on google earth and you can see that was his only option.  He was down to 1,300 feet when he reached the river. :o

Kevin

Very intresting! Love things like that!

Have some software on the laptop (acarsd maybe?) that displays planes on a map and the flight info. Can do it over the internet or by plugging it into my scanner!  :)

There is a box that you can get which will directly receive and plot the ADS-B data from the aircraft's Mode-S transponder.

http://www.hamradio.co.uk/kinetic-sbs-1e.shtml

It's not exactly cheap but it's quite mesmerising to have a play with. You can sit in the above shop and watch all the traffic coming into and out of Heathrow. In addition to the ADS-B information (heading, speed, position, altitude, etc.) It captures the aircraft's 24 bit ICAO address, looks it up in various online databases and works out the type and regsitration of the aircraft, the carrier, finds its' flight plan and identifies what service it is operating, etc.  8-)

A plane spotter's dream.

Sadly, a little too expensive to buy just as a "toy".

I believe it can publish info to the web, so you might find people have set these up for public access.

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Kevin Wood on 17 January 2009, 01:39:25
Hmm. Just looked at ACARSD and it looks interesting. Won't update as often as position information via Mode-S but it's easier to receive and decode. Might have a go at that sometime. Looks like you can just bunbg the output from an air band receiver into your sound card.

Kevin
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Ian_D on 17 January 2009, 18:20:23
Quote
Quote
Quote
You can see it all replayed here:

http://www4.passur.com/lga.html

Set date to Jan 15th, time to 15:25 and range to 10 miles.

You can see AWE1549 take off in green a minute or two in, from the centre of the sceen heading upwards. Climbs to about 3,400 feet and then starts a rapid descent followed by a tight turn to the left to reach the river. You can see one light aircraft heading up the river the opposite way at 1,000 feet take avoiding action and then go back for a look, accompanied by another, which seems to hover in the area.

Have a look at La Guardia on google earth and you can see that was his only option.  He was down to 1,300 feet when he reached the river. :o

Kevin

Very intresting! Love things like that!

Have some software on the laptop (acarsd maybe?) that displays planes on a map and the flight info. Can do it over the internet or by plugging it into my scanner!  :)

There is a box that you can get which will directly receive and plot the ADS-B data from the aircraft's Mode-S transponder.

http://www.hamradio.co.uk/kinetic-sbs-1e.shtml

It's not exactly cheap but it's quite mesmerising to have a play with. You can sit in the above shop and watch all the traffic coming into and out of Heathrow. In addition to the ADS-B information (heading, speed, position, altitude, etc.) It captures the aircraft's 24 bit ICAO address, looks it up in various online databases and works out the type and regsitration of the aircraft, the carrier, finds its' flight plan and identifies what service it is operating, etc.  8-)

A plane spotter's dream.

Sadly, a little too expensive to buy just as a "toy".

I believe it can publish info to the web, so you might find people have set these up for public access.

Kevin

Looks good, but too expensive for me!
Title: Re: Plane crash, not a joke.
Post by: Ian_D on 17 January 2009, 18:23:44
Quote
Hmm. Just looked at ACARSD and it looks interesting. Won't update as often as position information via Mode-S but it's easier to receive and decode. Might have a go at that sometime. Looks like you can just bunbg the output from an air band receiver into your sound card.

Kevin
Yes thats right, I plug my MVT-7100 straight into the microphone port on the laptop, and it works fine - just have to make sure the scanners volume is fairly low first, as it should go in the line in really, however my laptop doesnt have one unless its in its docking station!

Leave the scanner scanning, and as soon as it picks something up, ACARSD decodes it. :y