Thanks Entwood
I was trying not to move on to discussing the solenoid 
I agree that the solenoid is simply a hoofing great relay that just happens to be used to whack the the starter gear into engagement before it makes a big electrical contact but I really did believe that there was another relay hidden behind the glove box.
My old range rover has a pre-engaged starter with a solenoid on the side and it also has a relay which makes a very audible click when you turn the key.
My early Omega had a relay the clicked behind the glove box but with the benefit of a little reflection I now realise that it must have been the alarm imobiliser (it could stop the engine firing but it couldn't stop the starter from turning)
Not a problem mate ....

I'm just thinking that IF the AA man attached 12V directly to the low voltage side, the solenoid pulled in and the starter turned.. then it proves the switch side must be where the fault lies.
I don't see how connecting 12V directly to the drive side would actaully start the engine, as the mechanism would not have "moved across" if you get my drift..

So I'm starting to agree with you ... a fault in the low current side from the ignition switch down to the starter, which probably means the switch contacts or a broken wire .. ??
