I have a lot of respect for Stoners talent and desire to win on the track. I just happen to believe that great though he is,he isnt and never will be on Rossi,s level. I have wartched bike racing at all levels since the mid 70,s and I have no doubt whatsoever that Rossi is by far the greatest short circuit racer there has ever been,he is the 2 wheel equivelant of Senna and perhaps Stoner is the two wheeled Mansell - great but not quite on the same level as the greatest.
Off the bike,Rossi is a clever showman/businessman. He has built up and sold "brand Rossi" to a global audience.Not the way I would cunduct my life in his position but I cant blame him e for doing it.Particularily when he does it with the typical Itialian style and flair he utilises.
Off the bike Stoner (like Mansell) is a whinger,is never wrong,always looking for someone to blame. Honest ? hes not even honest with himself. I dont really care about any of that crap tbh, I simply believe that hes a great rider but he isnt on Rossi,s level,end of.
Im not a Rossi fan because of his statistics either.My favourite riders of the last 15 years are Haga,Walker and Gary McCoy,who dont have a title between them. Similarily My all time favourite Ferrari driver is Villenueve,whose statistics show a few wins and no titles,but my least favourite Ferrari driver (and driver of any description) is Scumacher who I detest, and who happens to be statistically the most succesful driver of all time.
The bottom line is we are all entitled to our opinion.The only possible way the Rossi/Stoner debate could be settled is for them both to be riding the same bike,and it looks like that will never happen now that Stoner is retiring.
I happen to have some sympathy with Stoners reasoning (if its genuine). MotoGp (and bike racing in general) is in decline and the next set of rules will probably make things worse rather than better.Globally the biking frenzy of the last 15 years has tailed off and its returning to being a minority interest. Maybe moreso here in Britland where all the blokes who bought into Fogarty (and then Hodgson) mania and went out and bought a Fireblade or whatever have now moved onto playing Golf (if they didnt wipe themselves out in the meantime). They were the types who invaded the track at Silverstone when Mansell won,not realising that there were 20 other cars still racing at 200mph, who waived union jacks at Brands every time Foggy appeared on the track.One of them actually said to me "If this young Rossi kid is so good,why doesnt he step up to WSB and race against Foggy ?".

Now,theyve found a new hero in Rory McIlroy,and found out in the process that its possible for someone from some part of Ireland to be a Brit.
